top of page
Writer's pictureJe-Ree

Abbott Elementary Season 4 Episode 4: "Costume Contest" Review: Halloween Hilarity and Heartfelt Lessons



Abbott Elementary returns with a Halloween episode that captures the spirit of the season while delivering plenty of laughs and character moments. Though it has big shoes to fill after the iconic Thanos-themed episode from Season 2, this installment proves to be a worthy competitor.


The episode opens with a fantastic array of costumes that showcases the show’s sharp humor. Mr. Johnson steals the spotlight once again, this time as Emo Jimmy Butler—his costumes are always a standout, demonstrating the writers’ knack for pop culture references that resonate with viewers. Jacob’s choice of Pat Sajak, albeit a bit misguided, provides a humorous counterpoint, especially as he remains blissfully unaware of the host's controversial views.


Janine and Gregory's ambitious couple's costume as a mosquito trapped in amber and Mr. DNA from Jurassic Park is both cute and absurd. Their confidence in their creativity leads to a comedic downfall as their peers struggle to understand their reference. This delightful misunderstanding perfectly captures the show's blend of wit and warmth. As a huge fan of Jurassic Park, the costumes were not headass!





Barbara’s storyline about giving up her beloved tradition of bobbing for apples due to parental complaints feels a bit repetitive, but Sheryl Lee Ralph’s performance brings depth to her character. Barbara’s struggle to adapt reflects a broader theme of change that resonates with many viewers, even if it’s been explored before.


As Barbara attempts to entertain her students with spooky storytelling, it’s clear that the kids aren't having it. The moment she resorts to bobbing for apples herself is both hilarious and a bit desperate, further emphasizing her commitment to keeping traditions alive—even if the kids don’t care for them.


Shoutout to Cree Summer and the nod the writers gave to her with that line from Barbara about her possibly not being able to do a lot of voices. Any one that knows Cree Summer's work in animation knows she can do a million different voices.


The school’s costume contest takes a turn when Melissa, dressed as her guinea pig Sweet Cheeks, steals the show and wins unanimously, leaving Janine and Gregory feeling deflated. Their competitive spirit contrasts sharply with the fun atmosphere, highlighting how their need for validation can sometimes overshadow their genuine connection.


Jacob’s participation and the students' lack of recognition for Pat Sajak adds a layer of comedy, while also triggering Barbara’s feelings about change. The escalating chaos culminates in Barbara’s comical attempt to force applause for Jacob, showcasing the show’s knack for blending heartfelt moments with absurdity.





I do feel bad for Jacob as he was a apart of the group of teachers the students don't like. I mean how can you not like Jacob? The parents need to have a talk with these students.


The evening shifts to Rubenstein's, where the teachers let loose. Barbara and Melissa's conversation about creating new traditions is heartwarming and relatable, especially as they decide to embrace a more adult form of apple bobbing—bobbing for shots.


Janine and Gregory’s realization that their competitive nature got in the way of their relationship is a sweet moment. Their decision to return to their original costumes underscores the importance of celebrating the unique connection they share, regardless of what others think.


This Halloween episode of Abbott Elementary balances humor, character growth, and the challenges of embracing change. The mix of absurdity and heartfelt moments—like Barbara's struggles and Janine and Gregory's journey—creates a delightful viewing experience. As always, the show's clever writing and strong character dynamics leave us eagerly anticipating what’s next. Now, to start brainstorming those Housewives-themed costumes for next year!



What did you think?

  • Loved it

  • Hated it

  • So/So


Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page