top of page
Writer's pictureRachel

'Doc' Season 1, Episode 1 "If at First You Don't Succeed" Review: Turbulent Characters and New Beginnings


The TV series Doc, based on an Italian original, begins with a tone that feels more like a soap opera than a medical drama. The first episode primarily focuses on establishing the characters, setting, and plot, which means it can feel a bit disjointed, a typical challenge for many shows when they lay the foundation. The introduction of the characters is scattered, and it takes some time to get a sense of who they are and how they fit into the larger story.


Dr. Michael Hamda, the one truly sympathetic character introduced so far, stands out as someone with redeeming qualities. He seems to be the kind of person who genuinely cares about his colleagues and his patients, and it’s refreshing to see that in a medical drama, where compassion can sometimes take a backseat to the action and drama. On the flip side, many of the other characters leave a lot to be desired. Dr. Larsen, for example, is portrayed as blunt, rude, and having a cold bedside manner. It’s hard not to feel frustrated with her as she interacts with a 22-week-pregnant patient, creating unnecessary stress with her distant demeanor. While Dr. Larsen is undoubtedly a skilled doctor, her approach to patient care is lacking. It’s a stark reminder that competence alone isn’t always enough to make someone a great healthcare provider.



DOC: Scott Wolf in the series premiere of DOC airing Tuesday, Jan. 7 (9:00-10:00 PM ET/PT) on FOX. CR: FOX. ©2025 FOX Media LLC.





Dr. Heller, who is introduced early on, seems to be another character with a lot of layers. Initially, we see him talking to his daughter about Halloween costumes, which humanizes him a bit. But his deferential behavior towards Dr. Larsen—buying her coffee and generally seeming to go out of his way to please her—suggests there’s more to their relationship. It doesn’t take long for us to learn that Dr. Heller and Dr. Larsen are romantically involved, which complicates their professional dynamic. His actions throughout the episode feel a bit suspicious, and it’s clear that he’s hiding something. His character remains enigmatic, and I can’t help but feel that his true motives will be revealed as the show unfolds.


Dr. Miller is yet another character who raises red flags. His defensive reactions when Dr. Larsen orders an autopsy on one of his deceased patients suggest there’s something he's not sharing. His cold, almost detached demeanor when he accepts the role of interim chief after Dr. Larsen’s accident adds another layer to his character—he seems to be more focused on power than on the well-being of his colleagues. While it’s still early in the series, I get the sense that Dr. Miller’s ambitions could lead him down a morally questionable path.


Then there’s Dr. Sonya Maitra, whose motivations seem shrouded in mystery. Her possible jealousy towards Dr. Larsen and Dr. Miller’s relationship hints at some tension, and it’s clear that she may not be as loyal as one would hope in a medical setting. Her character leaves us with a lot of questions, and I’m curious to see if she’ll become a more prominent player in the unfolding drama.


But perhaps the most compelling aspect of the first episode is Dr. Larsen’s transformation. After her accident, which causes her to lose the memory of the last eight years of her life, she faces the difficult task of coming to terms with the fact that her marriage ended, her son is no longer with her, and her daughter is no longer part of her life. The amnesia provides an opportunity for a fresh start, and as viewers, we’re left to wonder: Will Dr. Larsen emerge as a better doctor and a better person? While her abrasive behavior prior to the accident was hard to swallow, the potential for growth is evident, and it’s clear that many of the characters are watching her closely as she navigates this painful, yet possibly transformative, journey.

The show teases several mysteries, with most of the main characters harboring secrets that will likely unfold in later episodes.



DOC: Molly Parker in the series premiere of DOC airing Tuesday, Jan. 7 (9:00-10:00 PM ET/PT) on FOX. CR: FOX. ©2025 FOX Media LLC.


The first episode focuses heavily on character development, but there’s also a patient case that hints at Dr. Larsen’s skills as a doctor, even before the accident. Her ability to diagnose correctly, despite her prickly demeanor, shows that her expertise is not to be underestimated. It’s clear that Dr. Larsen’s medical prowess will be a key aspect of the show, and I’m eager to see how it plays into the bigger picture.


The episode sets the stage for a deeper exploration of Dr. Larsen’s recovery, and I’m particularly intrigued by how her memory loss will impact her interactions with both patients and colleagues. As her memories resurface, the way she approaches her work and her relationships could be completely altered, and that’s a dynamic I’m looking forward to watching unfold.


While the personal lives of the characters will undoubtedly drive much of the drama, the medical cases provide an interesting backdrop for the series. These cases will give the characters room to grow and develop as doctors, and they’ll also reveal more about the complex relationships that have evolved over the past eight years—relationships that will likely shape how the characters are perceived by the audience. It’s a reminder that even in a medical setting, the line between personal and professional lives is often blurred.





The episode concludes with Dr. Larsen reaching out to her ex-husband, Dr. Michael Hamda, for help in becoming the doctor she always hoped to be. This is a moment that signals a possible redemption arc for her, and I can’t help but feel that it will be a pivotal turning point in the series. Meanwhile, the image of a pregnant woman at Dr. Hamda’s home adds a layer of intrigue to his personal life, hinting at complications that could affect both his work and his relationship with Dr. Larsen. It’s clear that the show is setting the stage for a deep dive into these intertwined personal and professional dynamics in future episodes.


Overall, the first episode sets up a promising foundation for the series, with compelling characters and intricate relationships. I’m excited to see how the drama unfolds, particularly with Dr. Larsen’s amnesia and her quest for personal growth. I’m hoping that the show will continue to explore the delicate balance between personal and professional lives, and that the characters will continue to evolve in ways that make them more complex and relatable as the story progresses.



What did you think?

  • Loved it

  • Hated it

  • So/So


bottom of page