High Potential Episode 11 dives deep into the complexities of a decade-old murder case, where the deathbed confession of an elderly man throws the Donovan family into a whirlwind of truth and lies. The confession centers around Barry Johnson, the victim, whose death years ago was believed to be a tragic accident—until this confession, which claims that Barry’s son-in-law, George Donovan, killed him by pushing him down a flight of stairs. The unexpected twist of this confession shakes the characters to their core, especially Lt. Selena Soto (Judy Reyes), who has a history with the case.
From the outset, the tension is palpable when Lt. Melon (Garret Dillahunt) and his partner show up to gloat over solving the cold case. They bring champagne, bragging about their success, and it’s clear that their joy is more about proving their point than solving a murder. The moment is both frustrating and revealing for Selena, who has been holding onto her own suspicions about the case for years. The fact that they solved it without even properly examining the whole picture bothers her deeply, and you can almost feel the weight of her unresolved feelings—this case is one that has haunted her.
The narrative takes a turn as Selena explains the cold case to Morgan (Kaitlin Olson), who wasn’t entirely familiar with the details, given that she was busy with her children at the time. I found this part of the episode especially interesting because it shows how time and perspective shift how we approach things. Selena remembers the case vividly, but for Morgan, it’s almost like a distant memory. The murder of Barry, which seemed like an open-and-shut case years ago, starts unraveling with new details that weren’t previously considered. The more we learn, the more it becomes clear that something doesn’t add up about George’s confession.
Selena’s determination to get to the truth is inspiring. She doesn’t give up on this case, even when others seem content with a quick and easy resolution. I really respect how she insists on going through the old files, trying to piece together what went wrong. It’s a personal thing for Selena—this case is the one that got away, and it’s been eating at her for a decade. Morgan, to her credit, picks up on her frustration and throws herself into the investigation, which eventually leads to her breakthrough moment as she folds laundry at home. Her "a-ha" moment feels like a reward for her diligence, and it’s a reminder that sometimes answers come from the most unexpected places.
The key moment of the episode comes when Morgan realizes that Barry wasn’t pushed down the stairs, as originally suspected. Instead, he was electrocuted in the upstairs bathroom, and his body was then shoved down the laundry chute, resulting in the broken neck and the blood found on George’s shirt. The sheer level of detail in Morgan’s discovery is fascinating. I also appreciated how the show didn’t just rely on the obvious clues but brought in something as small as the scorch marks on a wall plate to finally crack the case open. It felt like a reminder that in crime-solving, sometimes the smallest detail can be the key to unlocking everything.
One of the most poignant parts of this episode for me was the family’s response to the investigation. It’s heartbreaking to watch as the Donovan family, especially Lenore (Barry’s wife), realizes that their years of trying to move on from Barry’s murder have been clouded by lies and unresolved truths. The tension between protecting family secrets and seeking justice is palpable, and it feels almost like a painful exorcism for the Donovans. The emotional weight of these revelations really hits home—this wasn’t just a case of who did it, but how it affected an entire family.
When Cody (Barry’s son) is revealed to be the true killer, it’s both tragic and understandable. His actions stemmed from a deep well of pain and anger over his father’s abuse of his mother. The moment when Cody confesses—especially the twist that he had already confessed to his grandfather, prompting the deathbed confession—was both heartbreaking and haunting. It was clear that this secret had been eating away at him, and by the end of the episode, it was a relief that he was finally ready to take responsibility. I felt for Cody; his actions, while wrong, were fueled by a sense of protectiveness over his mother, and it’s hard not to sympathize with that.
The way the show handles the Donovans' reactions to the truth is equally compelling. Heather (Barry’s wife) tries to take the blame for the murder, likely out of a sense of guilt or shame, but Selena’s reassurance that Cody will face justice as a minor adds an extra layer of complexity. It’s a tough situation, and the show doesn’t shy away from the messiness of it all. It’s clear that Cody’s confession is the final piece to the puzzle, but the emotional fallout is far from over.
In the closing moments, I found myself reflecting on Selena’s growth as a character. She’s been the emotional core of this series, and it was gratifying to see her unwavering commitment to the truth pay off. While Captain Pacheco (the ever-dutiful, by-the-book boss) begrudgingly acknowledges her success, the episode ends on a bittersweet note. Selena’s quiet confidence, paired with her and Morgan’s mutual respect for one another, gives us a glimpse of the strong partnership they’ve built.
Morgan’s surprise at finding a badge pinned to her jacket was a beautiful touch, a symbolic gesture showing that she’s earned her place in this team. It’s a moment of personal growth, not just for Morgan, but for Selena too, as she recognizes Morgan’s potential as a valuable ally. The episode ends on an uplifting note, but the complexities of the case and its emotional weight linger long after the credits roll.
High Potential Episode 11 is a masterclass in balancing crime-solving with emotional storytelling. It reminds us that behind every case, there are real people with real lives, and the journey to the truth can be messy, heartbreaking, and cathartic all at once.
What did you think?
Loved it
Hated it
So/So
Comments