Matlock Season 1, Episode 11, titled "A Traitor in Thine Own House," picks up right where last week’s intense episode left off, and the drama is only escalating. The episode kicks off with Maddy and Edwin testing her ability to lie using a lie detector test. Maddy, ever determined, is working on refining her skills to trick Shae, who’s become increasingly suspicious of her. The tension is high, especially with Sarah still furious about Maddy’s decision to give Billy her case. It’s clear that Sarah’s resentment has now turned into full-blown obsession, and she teams up with Shae—someone who also has it out for Maddy—to dig into Maddy’s past.
As Sarah and Shae join forces, Sarah’s anger boils over, and she lashes out at Billy in a fit of frustration. She throws some truly hurtful comments his way, even telling him that everyone at work knows she’s a better lawyer than him. Ouch. It’s as if this final jab from Sarah drives a wedge between them for good, and their friendship is left in tatters. I couldn’t help but feel for Billy in this moment, but also—Maddy’s deceit is the real reason Sarah’s spiraling. The episode starts to shift the audience's sympathy, making us question whether Maddy’s personal vendetta is worth all the collateral damage to those around her. Sure, she’s on a mission to uncover the truth about her daughter’s death, but what about the innocent people who are being dragged into her web of lies?
As for Maddy’s conflict with Shae, things take a turn when Matty files a complaint to HR in an attempt to get Shae—and Sarah—to stop snooping into her past. But Shae is relentless and manages to track down what she believes is a lead on Maddy’s former co-worker. She flies out to Georgia to speak with him, unaware that Maddy has orchestrated the whole thing. It’s a clever move on Maddy’s part—she has Edwin posing as the co-worker, throwing Shae off the trail. This strategic move finally forces Shae and Sarah to back off. For now.
The episode takes an emotional turn when Sarah has a breakdown in Olympia’s office, pouring her heart out about her feelings of betrayal. In a somewhat surprising moment, Olympia agrees to take Sarah under her wing and become her mentor. I don’t know about you, but I can already sense that this mentorship might not go smoothly. What could go wrong, right? But, with Olympia’s nerves on edge, I’m left wondering how long it’ll take before she uncovers the truth about Maddy’s manipulations.
Meanwhile, Olympia’s personal life is taking a nosedive. Her messy divorce from Julian is getting uglier by the minute. Olympia wants to see the accounting for the family trust, but Maddy is just using this as an opportunity to check if Julian’s behind the missing documents. I can’t help but feel that the tension between Olympia and Julian could have been more fleshed out, especially since Julian seems to be relegated to quick, tension-filled arguments with Olympia rather than getting a chance to shine in court. Then of course there is that embarrassing moment in Elijah's office. Olympia clearly wants to rekindle things with Elijah but he has moved on.
In another subplot, Senior returns this week, asking Olympia for help with a case. When Olympia (and team) uncovers that the client is lying she makes it clear how much she despises dishonesty. It’s a telling moment, and I couldn’t help but wonder if this foreshadows how Olympia will react once she discovers Maddy’s web of lies. Olympia’s sharp instincts might make her a formidable opponent when the truth eventually comes to light. And then there’s Senior—he’s impressed by Olympia, but will it be enough for him to support her candidacy for partner over his own son? The drama is thickening, and I’m on the edge of my seat waiting to see where this goes. Speaking of Senior he confronts Maddy about going to HR about Shae - clearly giving her a veiled threat. What is the story there?
The final twist in the episode is a gut punch: Edwin has lied to Maddy about the email from their daughter’s friend. This revelation will surely add more fuel to the fire in the episodes to come. Maddy’s trust in Edwin might get shaken, and I’m really curious to see how this new twist will affect their relationship and her investigation.
"A Traitor in Thine Own House" was all about lying, betrayal, and the consequences of deceit. The episode cleverly highlights how Shae, who’s so quick to call Maddy out for being a liar, is also hiding her own secrets—like her affair with a co-worker. It’s almost poetic that Maddy’s world is full of lies, and the truth is slowly unraveling. As Olympia said, all these lies will eventually come to light, but the question is: which one will be exposed first? I’m hooked, and I can’t wait to see how this all plays out.
What did you think?
Loved it
Hated it
So/So
Comments