The Irrational Season 2, Episode 10 offered a lighter murder mystery, though the guest cast somewhat spoiled the reveal. While the solution was predictable, the episode still maintained an enjoyable tone, despite the final ten minutes becoming a bit far-fetched. Alec’s explanation of how magic relies on neuroscientific principles, like distracting the audience’s attention, was logical. However, Charles’ use of magic to cover his tracks pushed the boundaries of realism, making the conclusion feel a little silly.
The case itself was engaging, more so than the typical chase sequences found in procedural shows. While the magical box emitting purple smoke to disrupt the police investigation seemed implausible, the investigation and resolution still managed to hold interest.
The cold open, while lengthy, set the stage well for the magic show, and the interactions with the magicians added to the fun. The identity of the victim wasn’t immediately clear, which kept things intriguing. However, an alternate scenario where Helene was the one killed during the show would have provided a more direct motive for Alec to investigate, and it might have made the rival's role in the case clearer.
Helene’s choice of Adelaide as a volunteer for the magic trick seemed unrealistic. For such a complex illusion, a magician would typically prefer someone who is familiar with the trick's mechanics. Nevertheless, the setup remained solid despite some questionable details. The idea of someone sneaking onto the stage to commit murder without anyone noticing stretched believability, particularly with the lack of a scream from Adelaide. However, the framing of Helena was effective for advancing the plot, even if the preliminary evidence didn’t fully support her arrest.
The reveal that Charles was the perpetrator was unsurprising, given his well-established career playing good characters in past roles. His portrayal of a kind mentor figure quickly became suspicious, and his eventual darker nature was hinted at through his actions, especially his ability to open the magic box despite his supposed arthritis.
Kylie’s subplot, while contributing to the episode’s emotional tone, felt somewhat exaggerated. The focus on recovering stolen phones and investigating a partner who had gone silent seemed out of place, especially considering the FBI’s priorities. However, the subplot did mirror Alec and Rose’s relationship dynamics. Both Kylie and Joyce, like Alec and Rose, had to confront insecurities and fears about commitment, with both couples ultimately resolving their issues through open communication. This contrast to the usual TV drama, which often relies on misunderstandings and jealousy, was a refreshing touch.
Alec’s reluctance to remove his shirt due to his scars provided a poignant moment, drawing a parallel to issues of body image seen in other shows. Rose’s understanding response further highlighted their growing bond, strengthening the emotional core of their relationship.
Rating: ★★★☆☆
What did you think?
Loved it
Hated it
So/So
Comments