In Wild Cards Season 2, Episode 2, Once a Con a Time in the West, the episode dives deep into the complexities of personal relationships, family legacies, and the choices people are forced to make when their backs are against the wall. From the very start, Max is frustrated, feeling betrayed by the lies around him and mourning the opportunities he’s lost, particularly the chance to travel. However, he’s backed into a corner and must agree to a risky deal involving an egg in exchange for avoiding jail time and getting justice for his brother's killer. The stakes are high, and it’s clear that Max is struggling to reconcile his past mistakes with the dire circumstances he’s found himself in.
If there's one thing you can’t say about Wild Cards, it’s that it doesn't know how to keep its audience entertained. Season 2, Episode 2, "Once a Con a Time in the West," proves that the series is hitting its stride, with a perfect balance of case-of-the-week antics and deeper character exploration. This episode combines a ranch rivalry with the constant, simmering tension between its two leads, Max and Ellis, making it an engaging ride from start to finish.
First, the episode channels the wild, rough-and-tumble vibe of a Western, taking us to the heart of ranch drama with a multi-million-dollar horse at its center. The case—an attempted murder on a prized horse—becomes a perfect backdrop to explore the familial feuds, land disputes, and long-buried grudges that feel right out of the Hatfield's and McCoy's playbook. However, it’s not just the case that makes this episode fun. It’s also a chance to see Cole (Ellis) strut his stuff on horseback. The moment he gallops in like a cover model from a romance novel was as endearing as it was amusing, especially when Max—bless her heart—was clearly out of her element, especially when it came to horses. Their chemistry shines here, as Max leans on Ellis, who is as confident in the saddle as he is in navigating the tricky dynamics of their work together.
But let’s be real: the real star of this episode, and arguably the whole show, is Ally Sheedy. From her iconic '80s films like The Breakfast Club to now, Sheedy commands the screen with a subtle charm that elevates the procedural. In this episode, she plays a pivotal role in the horse murder investigation, bringing to life a complex character tangled in family secrets and vengeance. Sheedy’s presence adds both gravitas and a touch of wit to a case that could have been overshadowed by the show’s larger focus on Max and Ellis’s relationship. The storyline with her felt like a nice nod to family dramas, making the episode even more thrilling.
While the case itself was fairly predictable—eye brow raising vet = villain—you’re not really watching Wild Cards for the whodunit. It’s about how the investigation intersects with the characters’ personal lives. And here, Max and Ellis are at a crossroads. Their relationship remains one of the most captivating slow burns on TV right now. Max’s struggle with her feelings for Ellis is palpable, and the episode does a fantastic job of letting us feel that tension. There’s something bittersweet in watching her try to make amends for their past, knowing full well that the road back is paved with awkwardness, unresolved issues, and emotional baggage. Meanwhile, Ellis seems to be putting up walls, but the moment when he is visibly shaken by the idea of something happening to Max shows just how deeply he cares. You can’t help but root for them—despite their flaws and the rocky past.
Max’s bravery in confronting her feelings is compelling. She's unafraid to put herself out there, even knowing the risks involved in loving someone in her line of work. It’s this courage that makes her such an endearing character, and the episode takes full advantage of this emotional depth. Their dance together—a literal and metaphorical one—is beautiful and shows just how much they both need to face their past to build something new.
The episode also deftly touches on the larger con world that Max and Ellis inhabit. As Max reflects on her mentor, Jonathan Ashford (played by Martin Sheen), the idea that trust is both a luxury and a dangerous game takes center stage. Sheen’s appearance promises big things for the future of the season, and it's hard not to be intrigued by what’s to come as Max is forced to reckon with her profession and her heart. This thematic thread of loneliness versus connection is reinforced with the arrival of Sheen’s character, and it’s clear that he’ll play a crucial role in guiding Max through the trials she faces ahead.
While the case of the week adds flavor, it’s the ensemble moments—especially with Ricky and the sweet, tender dynamics between Max and Ellis—that really elevate the episode. Ricky, often an underrated part of the team, gets his moment here, and it’s delightful to see his bond with Max deepen in the details. The new apartment setup adds another layer of warmth and permanence that was lacking in their previous places, providing a stable backdrop for their evolving relationships.
As the episode closes, Max and Ellis are still at an impasse, but the foundation is laid for their eventual reconciliation. There’s something so relatable about watching them tiptoe around each other, not quite ready to give in to their feelings but clearly drawn to one another. Giacomo Gianniotti and Vanessa Morgan’s chemistry is electric, making their exchanges feel fresh, smart, and heartfelt.
In the aftermath of the confrontations, the characters are left reflecting on the importance of moving forward and repairing the fractured relationships that have defined so much of their lives. Max and Ellis may have received commendations for their work, but it’s clear that personal issues and lingering emotional wounds will continue to haunt them. The episode ends on a bittersweet note, showing that while progress is possible, true healing and reconciliation will take time.
What I find most compelling about this episode is how it balances action and emotional depth. The investigation itself is intriguing, but it’s the personal stakes—the choices made by individuals, the weight of their past actions, and the emotional toll of unresolved grudges—that really take center stage. The characters are complex, and it’s easy to see how each one’s past shapes their current decisions. In a way, this episode serves as a reminder that no one can escape the consequences of their past, but also that redemption and change are always within reach—if you’re willing to face the truth.
"Once a Con a Time in the West" is a standout episode that effortlessly blends character-driven drama with an intriguing case. The ranch rivalry is entertaining, but it's the emotional journey of Max and Ellis that makes this episode shine. Their journey is what keeps Wild Cards so compelling, and with the addition of Martin Sheen and Ally Sheedy, the show continues to prove that it knows exactly how to build a world where con artists and love collide. If you love a good slow-burn romance mixed with just the right amount of mystery and drama, this episode is a must-watch.
What did you think?
Loved it
Hated it
So/So
Comments