"Doomed To Die" really hit a mark! The absence of the show’s more distracting subplots have allowed the core narrative and character dynamics to shine through. Charlie Vickers is bringing complexity to Annatar/Sauron—his performance is a highlight for many fans. Celebrimbor’s journey, especially in the context of his interactions with Annatar, adds a fascinating layer to the story.
The gradual awakening of Celebrimbor to the manipulation around him adds a powerful layer of psychological drama. The repeated motifs, like the mouse and the missing ruby, cleverly build suspense and foreshadow the impending betrayal.
The dynamic between Celebrimbor and Annatar is really compelling, especially how Annatar twists the narrative to undermine Celebrimbor's credibility. That moment when Celebrimbor desperately tries to warn the others must have been heart-wrenching, especially as he spirals into paranoia, feeling isolated. The physical confrontation, with Annatar using magic to manipulate perceptions, is a classic but effective trope that heightens the stakes.
Cuffing Celebrimbor to the workbench is such a chilling image—it's not just a physical restraint but symbolizes his entrapment in this web of deceit.
Elrond and Durin's friendship is one of the show's standout elements! Their reunion and the dynamic between them really seem to capture that sense of camaraderie and loyalty that’s so integral to the story. Elrond's plea for help adds a lot of emotional weight, especially knowing the stakes involved.
Durin’s leadership and the conflict within Khazad-dûm create a compelling tension. The rousing speech is classic epic storytelling, but it’s the looming threat of the king digging deeper that raises the stakes even more. You can feel the impending doom, especially when Elrond’s faith in Durin starts to falter.
That moment where Elrond kneels in despair is powerful. The comparison to William Wallace is fitting; both characters embody that deep sense of hope against overwhelming odds. It sounds like the episode really leveraged those emotional beats effectively, keeping you invested in the characters’ struggles.
That twist with Elrond and Galadriel definitely sounds like a moment that could’ve gone off the rails! The idea of them having a romantic connection feels out of place in Tolkien's lore, but it’s good to hear it was ultimately a clever tactic rather than a serious development. The kiss as a ruse adds a layer of intrigue, even if it does toe the line of absurdity.
Elrond's willingness to risk so much for Galadriel speaks volumes about their bond, and it showcases his character's depth and resourcefulness. It’s interesting how the show balances these moments of tension with lighter, even slightly ridiculous, elements. The key is that it doesn’t undermine the larger stakes at play.
However, it’s clear that the core relationships—like that between Annatar and Celebrimbor—could have served as a strong foundation for the series, anchoring it more firmly in Tolkien's lore. The rush to create the Rings of Power and the way it has been intertwined with other plots seems to dilute the impact of key storylines.
The issues with the dwarven plot, particularly the rapid descent of Durin III, also highlight missed opportunities for character development. If their relationship had been more solidified earlier on, the stakes would feel much higher now as the conflict deepens.
As for the knowledge of the Balrog and the logistics of the dwarven host, those are significant gaps that can take viewers out of the story. It’s tough when the internal logic of the world feels inconsistent, especially in a series that draws so heavily from established lore.
The writing continues to be a mixed bag, which is frustrating, especially when you can see glimpses of potential. Celebrimbor’s line about light overcoming darkness is a strong sentiment, but the excessive elaboration definitely dilutes its impact. It’s a common issue in shows where the dialogue could benefit from being tighter and more impactful.
The “fast-travel” moments are a real sticking point too. Having Arondir show up conveniently feels like a missed opportunity for deeper character development and continuity. It would have been much more satisfying to see him journeying toward Eregion with a clearer purpose, rather than popping up at the last moment.
Rian's death definitely seems like a misstep. The “Boromir treatment” works best when the character has had enough development to make the sacrifice feel meaningful. Rian, being more of a background character, lacks the emotional weight for such a dramatic moment to resonate. Arondir’s near-death experience feels similarly anticlimactic, especially if it’s unlikely he’ll actually stay dead.
The inconsistency in character arcs and the way stakes are presented can leave viewers feeling detached from the narrative. It’s disappointing when the series introduces characters only to sideline their development or give them unsatisfying arcs. With all these issues, do you think there are specific changes that could help realign the show with its potential in future seasons?
Drop a comment and vote in our Reader's Poll below!
What did you think of the episode?
Loved it
Hated it
Comments