top of page

'Watson' Season 1 Episode 3 "Wait for the Punchline" Review

Writer's picture: RachelRachel

Episode 3 of Watson really turns up the intensity and delves deeper into the personal lives and struggles of the characters, while still keeping the medical mysteries at the forefront. Watson’s ongoing battle with the side effects from the pills Shinwell gave him continues to create a palpable sense of unease, and I find myself getting more and more frustrated with both Watson and Shinwell. It’s clear that Shinwell has the power to come clean and help Watson, but instead, he continues to keep secrets, putting both of their lives in jeopardy. Watson is clearly losing control—his hallucinations of Holmes and Moriarty are more than just symptoms of his physical condition; they represent the mental weight he's carrying from his past, his guilt, and his inability to confront his current reality. His spiraling behavior is hard to watch, especially when he becomes so consumed by his inner turmoil that he’s essentially driving away the people who care about him.


On the other hand, the way Watson tries to maintain his professional facade is impressive. He may be struggling internally, but his brilliance as a doctor and detective hasn’t diminished. His quick thinking when he takes on the case of Molly Jones shows that despite his own personal chaos, he can still be the calm, rational presence when needed. Molly’s case is one of the most interesting and emotional parts of the episode, and it’s a relief to see that Watson’s sharp instincts aren’t clouded by his own issues. The big reveal—that Molly’s mother didn’t kill her children, but that they died from a rare heart condition—was a powerful moment. It’s a reminder of the layers of complexity in medical cases and human relationships. For Watson, the case seems almost personal, perhaps because he’s grappling with his own guilt over what’s happening to him. In some ways, solving Molly’s case feels like a redemption arc for Watson. It’s a little moment of triumph amidst all the chaos.





Molly herself is a fascinating character. Her story about growing up believing her mother was a killer, only to learn that her mother is not the monster she thought, is heartbreaking. It must be such a difficult truth to confront, and I loved the way Watson helped her come to terms with it. There’s something so human about how Watson relates to his patients. He doesn’t just treat them medically—he digs deep into their emotional and psychological issues as well. It’s one of the things that makes his character interesting. However, the fact that he’s now hiding his own truth from everyone around him complicates things, and I’m genuinely curious to see how long he can keep up the charade before it all falls apart.



Morris Chestnut as Dr. John Watson and Djouliet Amara as Molly Jones Photo: Eduardo Araquel/CBS ©2024 CBS Broadcasting, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Morris Chestnut as Dr. John Watson and Djouliet Amara as Molly Jones Photo: Eduardo Araquel/CBS ©2024 CBS Broadcasting, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Then there’s the drama among Watson’s team, which is still very much front and center. The tension between the twins is definitely something to keep an eye on. Stephens’ anger towards his brother for dating his ex feels so raw, and it’s hard to not sympathize with him. Family dynamics like that are always messy, but watching how it affects their work relationship is fascinating. I think it’s a subtle but important part of the episode because it shows how personal issues spill over into professional settings, affecting everyone involved. Ingrid’s subplot about wanting to be better at lying is equally interesting. At first, it might seem like a quirky detail, but I have a feeling it’s going to come into play in a bigger way. Ingrid’s character is still a bit of a mystery, and I’m curious to see how her desire to improve her lying skills will manifest. It almost feels like a coping mechanism for her, a way to deal with whatever personal issues she’s not ready to confront. Her interactions with Watson are intriguing—there’s definitely some chemistry there, and I wonder if it’s something the show will explore further.


Speaking of personal lives, Sasha’s subplot was incredibly heartbreaking. It’s clear she’s struggling with her engagement, especially after finding the ring and realizing that her fiancé has been dragging his feet on proposing. The fact that he casually says “soon” when she confronts him about it speaks volumes about the emotional distance between them. I think this will be a major storyline as the season progresses, especially since Sasha’s unhappiness is such a stark contrast to the more professional side of the show. The tension between what’s happening in her personal life and how she handles her work at the clinic adds complexity to her character. It makes me wonder how she’s going to cope with this relationship problem, and if it will affect her role within the team. Could her unhappiness in her personal life start to seep into her work? It’s something I’m eager to see unfold.


And then there’s Watson himself, who is clearly becoming more unhinged as the episode progresses. His emotional instability reaches a new level when he spies on his soon-to-be ex-wife during a lunch date with her new girlfriend. This was a very uncomfortable scene, and it perfectly encapsulated how far Watson has fallen. His desperation is palpable, and it almost feels like he’s holding on to the past in a way that’s unhealthy. It’s tough to watch, but it’s also fascinating to see how this emotional breakdown is affecting him and those around him. Watson’s inability to let go, combined with his mental and physical decline, creates such a compelling tension that will likely continue to play a big role in future episodes. I’m also intrigued by his complicated relationship with Shinwell, as they seem to be locked in this toxic cycle where neither is being fully honest with the other.





In terms of the case itself, the way Watson works with the twins to solve Molly’s mystery and clear her mother’s name was truly satisfying. It’s rare that a show can balance the medical drama with real, emotional depth, and Watson does it well. By the end of the episode, there’s a sense of accomplishment, but also so many unresolved personal issues that are bubbling beneath the surface. The reveal about the mother’s innocence and Watson’s ability to clear her name is a moment of triumph, but it doesn’t change the fact that Watson is falling apart. There’s a real sense of dread as we approach the eventual revelation about the pills, and I can’t help but feel like Watson’s world is about to come crashing down.


Overall, this was an excellent episode. It was emotionally intense, with personal and professional stakes intertwined in a way that kept me hooked. The mysteries were compelling, the character dynamics were rich, and the personal struggles of the characters, particularly Watson, provided a deep emotional backbone to the story. I’m genuinely excited to see where the series goes from here, especially with the growing tension between Watson’s lies, his health issues, and his relationships. There’s a lot more to unpack, and I have a feeling this season is going to be full of emotional twists and turns.



What did you think?

  • Loved it

  • Hated it

  • So/So


Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page